AAPL Stock: 117.16 ( -1.14 )

Printed from

Japanese court rules Samsung abused FRAND against Apple

updated 08:07 pm EDT, Sun May 18, 2014

Demand for sales ban and high royalties over SEPs deemed illegal

Samsung, which has often used Standards-Essential Patents (SEPs) or patents purchased from other companies in an effort to mount some kind of countersuit in cases where Apple has accused the Galaxy maker of stealing Apple's technology, was found guilty again in a Japanese appeals court of illegally using SEPs as legal weapons and not honoring its obligation under Fair, Reasonable And Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) guidelines.

When the owner of a patent declares it to be "standards-essential" -- meaning a modern device such as a smartphone couldn't perform its primary function without it -- the standards governing body insists that the holder license the patent at reasonable rates relative to the cost of the device, and to do so for any "willing licensee." Many (but not all) of the legal issues that Motorola Mobility and Samsung have sued Apple and others over involve attempts to obtain disproportionally high royalities or sales bans based on "infringement" of the SEPs.

This particular legal strategy has not worked out well for either company, and both Google and Samsung have been forced to drop some lawsuits against Apple and Microsoft due to pressure from governments and regulatory agencies who considered the actions illegal or anti-competitive. The Tokyo Court of Appeals, in the latest case, ruled that Samsung was guilty of abusing its SEPs and using them as legal and anti-competitive weapons rather than licensing them fairly.

In the Japanese case, reports AppleInsider, Samsung was attempting to use its patents relating to the 3GPP mobile standard against Apple, asking for a sales injunction against the iPhone 4 and non-SEP royalty rates. The case was very similar to the lawsuit Samsung brought against Apple at the US International Trade Commission in 2013. The ITC, contradicting its own previous judgements, found in Samsung's favor -- but the sales injunction was overturned by the Obama administration, citing the anti-competitive nature of the ruling and other flaws.

Similarly, Samsung was forced to drop SEP-related sales ban requests against Apple and other competitors in Europe after the European Union Court of Justice launched an investigation into Samsung's abusive behavior. As with other courts, the Japanese appeals court ruled that sales injunctions are not a legal remedy to the use of SEPs by parties that are negotiating in good faith.

In the first judgement in the case, the court found that Samsung was not negotiating in good faith, that it was illegally trying to win a sales ban over an SEP, and that Samsung had not been honest in reporting that its patent was an essential part of the 3GPP standard until two years after it was adopted. The court of appeals in this new finding, which held two hearings and solicited public comment, upheld the original ruling.

As a result, the court said that Apple should pay Samsung a maximum amount for the use of the 3GPP-related patent of $95,000 -- in line with what Apple would have expected to pay for a FRAND-guided royalty. In a statement on the case, Apple Japan praised the court's ruling and thanked it for protecting "the integrity of the international patent system," which the iPhone maker said Samsung had "recklessly ignored" in lawsuits around the globe.

Thus far, the only country that has agreed with Samsung that a sales ban is an appropriate remedy for SEP infringement has been the company's "home court" of South Korea.

by MacNN Staff



  1. apostle

    Junior Member

    Joined: 04-16-08

    SameSung is a business. It's only concern being profit. Making shareholders happy. Making money. Yes, SameSung as a company is morally bankrupt. It steals ideas from others in order to make money. It fights in court because the profit made by ripping off other peoples ideas far outweighs the penalties incurred by ripping off those ideas. But when has business ever been about morality?

    How many people in America mistakenly buy Walmart brand ketchup because the packaging is near identical to, say, Heinz packaging - and the customer simply mistook one for the other. Fess up!

    And ultimately need to accept the fact that most people buy product because they lack the ability to make an informed decision or are just too lazy to do the research. Probably Democrats.

    SameSung profits at the expense of ill-educated individuals.

    Own a Samsung product?

    Wake up and smell yourself! You are not as smart as you think. And SameSung has ripped You Off.

    Grow Up and take responsibility for yourself (or forever be an indentured loser)...

    And for those who disagree, how do you feel about the fact that Every.Bit.Of.Information you enter into your SameSung device is recorded and saved to a server in S.Korea. Your address book is saved to a SameSung server. Your Bank Acoount numbers and Passwords are saved to a server in S.Korea.

    Does this outrage you? It should. But not because of SameSung. These facts are detailed in your SameSung agreement.

    Don't be outraged by SameSung Policy. Be outraged that you were too stupid to read "your agreement".

    Wake Up and Smell Yourself!


  1. apostle

    Junior Member

    Joined: 04-16-08

    P.S. Somewhat unrelated, but KUDOs to Japan for trying to keep Godzilla (Gojira (sp?)) pure.

    I realize Japan (as regards this ) has gifted the world infinite preciously undefined possibilities. But for me, in the grand scheme of things, both morally and informatively, has done no better than offering the possible truth of a Godzilla (Gojira).

    Hey, it's not just a movie - it's a lesson. But then...

  1. coffeetime

    Senior User

    Joined: 11-15-06

    Thank you for reminding us how SamSucks really is.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.


Network Headlines

Follow us on Facebook


Most Popular


Recent Reviews

Ultimate Ears Megaboom Bluetooth Speaker

Ultimate Ears (now owned by Logitech) has found great success in the marketplace with its "Boom" series of Bluetooth speakers, a mod ...

Kinivo URBN Premium Bluetooth Headphones

We love music, and we're willing to bet that you do, too. If you're like us, you probably spend a good portion of your time wearing ...

Jamstik+ MIDI Controller

For a long time the MIDI world has been dominated by keyboard-inspired controllers. Times are changing however, and we are slowly star ...


Most Commented