AAPL Stock: 118.03 ( -0.85 )

Printed from

Microsoft joins Apple in EU complaints over Motorola patents

updated 09:50 am EST, Wed February 22, 2012

Microsoft says Motorola abusing video patents

Microsoft Deputy General Counsel Dave Heiner in a posting confirmed company was echoing Apple's strategy and filing a formal complaint against Motorola with the European Commission. The new dispute, like Apple's, alleges that Motorola is abusing standards-based patents by trying to charge unreasonable rates to license technology. Microsoft's case centered around elements like the H.264 video codec and Wi-Fi that are at the heart of Motorola's lawsuits both in Europe and the US.

The legal head and company VP argued that Motorola wasn't just throwing the concept of a standard into doubt but threatening to break basic technology, since a ban on Microsoft's use would prevent many from watching videos and getting online. "Imagine what a step back it would be if we could no longer watch videos on our computing devices or connect via Wi-Fi, or if only some products, but not others, had these capabilities," Heiner said. "That would defeat the whole purpose of an industry standard."

He added that Motorola was asking the same 2.25 percent royalty cut for the total price of a product, not individual components, that was being wielded against Apple over 3G. As an example, a $1,000 notebook would send $22.50 just to Motorola where the royalties owed to 29 other companies amounted to just two cents, or 20 cents at most. Attaching the royalty to the total product cost and not just Windows purportedly led to a disproportionate cost: a notebook twice as expensive would give Motorola $45, even if the H.264 and Wi-Fi uses didn't cost any more to implement than they did on the $1,000 PC.

Also singled out was Google's apparent hesitance to foreswear lawsuits over standards. Apple, Cisco, and Microsoft had all made pledges not to sue over standards patents under any condition, but the current refusals by Google and Motorola had cast doubt on the sincerity of wanting solely to protect Android. It was ironic that a company that wanted to protect the Internet was willing to risk breaking it, Heiner thought.

Microsoft did partly call its own sincerity into question by claiming that its own Android licensing system was an example of how to license properly. Although it has had some claims upheld by the ITC, others have been cast into doubt, both for validity and for the motivations that led Android makers to sign. Barnes & Noble revealed that it was being forced to sign a non-disclosure deal just to find out the exact licensing disputes leveled against it, making it impossible for the company or outside patent experts to publicly challenge Microsoft on its word. Many have noted that Microsoft makes more money on Android than Windows Phone and that companies often get licensing discounts if they agree to make Windows Phones, artificially boosting the platform's device share.

The EC complaint still increases the pressure on Motorola and its expected future parent Google now that there is a wider consensus on a possible issue with standards patents. As with Samsung, Motorola's only real defenses against lawsuits from Apple and Microsoft revolve around standards, and being forced to license at lower rates would leave it in a position of likely having to settle.

by MacNN Staff



  1. macastronomer

    Joined: Dec 1969


    Read Your Stuff

    I'm just wondering if you guys read your own stuff. It could use editing for clarity. That last sentence is a real doozie.

  1. global.philosopher

    Joined: Dec 1969


    This is crazy....

    According to Motorola if you have some of their patent such as 4G functionaility in a Mercedese-Benz (nuilt-in) then they want 2.25% of the entire car not the device component. Thats a lot of moola.

    What if you extend that out to a cruise liner or space shuttle?

  1. global.philosopher

    Joined: Dec 1969


    On another note...

    MS are stillthe evil empire but Google is fast catching up....noen the less this does not diminish MS status of questionable business tactics. Really....signing an NDA before it will show you what you are supposedly infringing. The reason is obvious...they want people to infringe and pay....if word gets out what is being infringed then technology companies will just rework it and then MS gets nothing. WinMo is a dud and MS knows it.

  1. Makosuke

    Joined: Dec 1969



    Wait, Motorola is one of the h264 patentholders? And, it would seem, trying to charge outrageous royalties for it? This obviously wasn't the issue before, but that adds a whole mess of sticky ethical and self-interest issues to Google's WebM vs. H264 deal.

    I don't necessarily think they would, but they could go out of their way to scuttle H264 now to get people locked into WebM, which although they're giving away free they still own. I don't think I ever will forgive Mozilla for what they did with HTML5 video, but it looks like Motorola is in a larger sense part of the problem.

  1. Zanziboy

    Joined: Dec 1969


    Punitive Action

    It's pretty crazy that Motorola can violate FRAND and patent exhaustion doctrine by demanding extortionate royalties for intellectual property given away under IETF and ETSI standards. The EU and the USPTO should revoke all claims Google and Motorola have to the 3G and H.264 standards in question on the basis that Motorola has used their participation in the IETF and ETSI as a means to create Trojan horses for the purpose of manipulating the market and thwarting competition. Google and Motorola have clearly conspired to violate both FRAND and the patent exhaustion doctrine in an attempt to defraud competitors.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.


Network Headlines

Follow us on Facebook


Most Popular


Recent Reviews

Ultimate Ears Megaboom Bluetooth Speaker

Ultimate Ears (now owned by Logitech) has found great success in the marketplace with its "Boom" series of Bluetooth speakers, a mod ...

Kinivo URBN Premium Bluetooth Headphones

We love music, and we're willing to bet that you do, too. If you're like us, you probably spend a good portion of your time wearing ...

Jamstik+ MIDI Controller

For a long time the MIDI world has been dominated by keyboard-inspired controllers. Times are changing however, and we are slowly star ...


Most Commented