AAPL Stock: 121.3 ( -1.07 )

Printed from

Universal tries to block TWiT show for mentioning MegaUpload

updated 11:05 pm EST, Wed December 14, 2011

Universal misuses DMCA to silence MegaUpload talk

Universal drew fire Wednesday after it appeared to be misusing the Digital Millennium Copyright Act to silence news of MegaUpload. The movie and TV studio had YouTube pull down an episode of TWiT's Tech News Today on Monday for including two clips of MegaUpload's celebrity-laden song endorsing its file transfer service. Show co-host Tom Merritt had the show back up after a dispute, but Universal issued a DMCA request on Tuesday and will manage to keep it down for at least 10 days following a counter-dispute from Merritt through YouTube.

A Universal lawsuit could follow if the studio sincerely believes there was a copyright violation, but it's unclear that it could or would go that far. As a news outlet, TWiT was using only partial clips under fair use for reporting. Suing could potentially backfire by establishing a legal precedent. Universal also doesn't own the rights to the MegaUpload song and can't claim a copyright violation.

Instead, Universal may have been simply exploiting YouTube policies and legal requirements to minimize talk of a service it doesn't like but which it doesn't have legal ground to attack. Unlike a service such as LimeWire or the original Napster, MegaUpload is used frequently for legal file transfers and has usually been responsive to takedown requests. The block wasn't a complete censorship, since TWiT hosts its own content, but would have conveniently taken down a news story on the world's largest video site during the time when it was most relevant.

The decision could underscore the concerns over the SOPA bill (Stop Online Piracy Act) and its possible overreach. While the DMCA often lets companies force individual pieces of content down while under dispute, SOPA could see whole sites taken offline, even if the potentially illegal content is just one user-submitted item. [via The Verge]

by MacNN Staff





  1. testudo

    Joined: Dec 1969



    They're claiming infringement not because the shown clip infringed their copyright, but that the service that the advertising song the clips came from might be used to infringe copyright? And that infringement itself is in dispute, since the only claim they have is on the artists, not the songs.

    You would think someone in power could look at this case specifically and go "Hey, wait! What are we doing? This system is open to misuse and abuse with the way it's set up. Let's fix it!"

    Oh, right, they do think that. Up until the lobbying guys send them a cache of cash.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.


Network Headlines

Follow us on Facebook


Most Popular


Recent Reviews

HP 14-x030nr 14-inch Chromebook

If you're like us, chances are you've come to realize that you need the ability to access the Internet on the go. Also, you've prob ...

15-inch MacBook Pro with Force Touch

Apple's 15-inch Retina MacBook Pro continues to be a popular notebook with professional users and prosumers looking for the ultimate ...

Typo keyboard for iPad

Following numerous legal shenanigans between Typo -- a company founded in part by Ryan Seacrest -- and the clear object of his physica ...


Most Commented