AAPL Stock: 110.78 ( -0.53 )

Printed from

Citigroup, Goldman Sachs conflict on Apple stock

updated 09:40 am EDT, Wed October 1, 2008

Citigroup vs. G. Sachs

New analysis of Apple's difficult financial situation has yielded two significantly different views. Richard Gardner of Citigroup has cut his price target for Apple stock by more than $100, down to $170 from $287. Blame is laid on a 3 percent decline in industry computer sales, and a 12 percent drop in music revenue throughout 2008. Apple's guidance, normally thought by analysts to be too conservative, may in fact prove accurate for the fourth quarter, Gardner suggests.

An EPS of $5.29 on sales of $32.68 billion is now predicted for FY08, which is just coming to a close, while FY09 figures are expected to produce an EPS of $5.43 off of $35.2 billion. Because Apple is set to grow, Gardner is still issuing a buy rating, with the observation that the company will likely outperform most rival computer, electronics and phone makers.

An analyst for Goldman Sachs, David Baily, has meanwhile kept to a higher stock target, at approximately $200. Monday's share slide more than compensated for any worries about growth in Mac sales, Baily contends, and Apple should be buoyed in the fourth calendar quarter by the iPhone. Shipments of 4.6 million iPhones and 2.7 million Macs are currently predicted for Apple's September financial quarter.

by MacNN Staff




  1. majormauser

    Joined: Dec 1969


    Stupid Stocks

    Ya everyone of them has been "right" for the last Year. Every-time they put out these fictitious numbers Apples Stock goes down. Look at the names GS,CG,GG they are all corrupt. Your stupid to buy into the market now.

  1. horvatic

    Joined: Dec 1969


    The industry is NOT APPLE

    Yea, the industry, but that's not Apple. Apple has been in a league by itself for the last two years beating all estimates that any of these IDIOTS have thrown. Apple has innovative products while the industry has the same old same old. Windows c*** that doesn't work or barely works if you can fend off the spyware and viruses everyday. And these people are the very same people that have probably caused are financial crises and are begging the government to bail them out. I bet that Apple beats the expectations AGAIN!

  1. sgirard

    Joined: Dec 1969



    Apple is not in a "difficult financial situation". On the contrary. Apple is positioned to ride out this crisis of liquidity much better than many of America's Fortune 500 firms. The CEO of AT&T said his firm is having trouble borrowing funds needed for operations. In contrast, Apple has $20B in cash and other current assets. Using the phrase "Apple's difficult financial situation" is a strange choice of words to explain the drop in Apple's share price over recent days.

  1. rtbarry

    Joined: Dec 1969


    difficult... situation? WHAT?!?

    they have $20B in the bank, have packed retail stores (yes, even now), consistently release successful products and they are highly profitable, you idiots. what difficult financial situation?

    the banking system finally tanks after decades of abuse, the stock market over-corrects and suddenly apple is in a "difficult financial situation"? even amidst the current chaos, they are still targeted for increased (that means "going up"), earnings and EPS. increased.

    MacNN, please find someone who has at least graduated middle school to start writing/editing for you. please.

  1. ClevelandAdv

    Joined: Dec 1969


    Stock Drop

    I guess I am an idiot. How does a 3% drop in PC sales relate to a 35% drop in their projected stock value. Especially
    when Apple sales are unlikely to be as adversely effected as other companies.

  1. rtbarry

    Joined: Dec 1969


    3... 2...

    (counting down to pointless, contrarian comment from testudo)

  1. mmmdoughnuts

    Joined: Dec 1969



    This is the prime time to invest!!!! If you believe that the economy will recover next week. It is the perfect time to invest if you think the economy will recover in 5 years. It all depends on when you want or expect to cash out.Buy Low sell high. I know of a few banks that are having a fire sale!!!

  1. chucker

    Joined: Dec 1969


    the wall

    but some PC companies are definitely going to the wall, especially as their mainstays - faceless corporate clients cut back on spending - that is going to make the computing landscape interesting again

  1. Guest

    Joined: Dec 1969


    check ur awareness level



    Congratulations, you are about to learn some of the biggest secrets of about your country & the proposed future world. We the people, need to act fast because they [private organizations] are acting faster than you think!


    America WAKE UP!!

    Born into the slavery of the PRIVATIZED monetary system (NOT UNDER TRUE GOVERNMENT CONTROL/ASSETS), without your awareness, it is now up to you to spread the knowledge and commit to re evaluating our existence.

    Vote for H.R 2755 Federal Reserve Abolition act - As President John F. Kennedy intended when he signed EXECUTIVE ORDER 1110 to eliminate the CFR, IRS, and Federal Reserve from Global tyranny!

    Also Presidential Canididates are appointed "compliant" by the CFR & Federal Reserve, as you will soon learn below... Do a "write in" vote for Ron Paul.


    Intro to the situation right now

    The Most important thing you need to know - The Purpose of NWO

    New World Order includes
    ...and who knows who else?

    Alex Jones asks a question that gets him arrested!

    Now, do you have ANY idea YOUR country's Think Tank has been up to?

    Wikipedia Operation Northwoods

    Sounds Familiar right? (9/11- inside job!)

    Federal Reserve Purpose

    Truth exposed by Ron Paul

    The Illuminati Circle EXPOSED

    Everything listed here is a private organization somehow related to the founders or co-founders, the Rockerfeller mafia (family) circle. Yet they are convinced they have a plan for the whole world!

    They are as federal as Federal Express, which means we can revoke their right to power since they are nothing but a private organization, no government agencies.

    By creating our own money system & banks. We can kick the federal reserve's asses out of existence and restore true Democracy once again in the USA!

    Then we won't need a civil war, but if the people need to fight for their lives, you bet we will organize and reach for the inner light & guidance to preserve the power to the good majority of people!

    Skull and Bones - 322 Yale Secret Society, started as an Anti-Freemason group

    Council of Foreign Relations (CFR) - Wikipedia

    CFR Media Control

    Trilateral Commision

    Bilderberg Secret Meetings

    Bilderberg Wikipedia

    Commission on Global Governance

    Race to the top, Muli-National Corporations (MNC) - Controlling the Government

    Population Council - Biochemical Capabilities

    What are you thinking about right now?
    Don't let their plan carry out!

    Look at what happened to the last real president -JFK

    Country's bloodline runs on fear

    Just to add to the awareness...

    Check your Air - Chemtrails

    Drugs in our Water? WTF!?!?

    We got to show 'em who's boss = R3VOLUTION

  1. testudo

    Joined: Dec 1969



    You can call me annoying, but at least I don't post stupid spam of youtube videos and call them 'proof' of something, all while under the disguise of a guest!

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.


Network Headlines

Follow us on Facebook


Most Popular


Recent Reviews

Polk Hinge Wireless headphones

Polk, a company well-established in the audio market, recently released a new set of headphones aimed at the lifestyle market. The Hin ...

Blue Yeti Studio

Despite being very familiar with Blue Microphones' lower-end products -- we've long recommended the company's Snowball line of mics ...

ZTE Spro 2 Smart Projector

Home theaters are becoming more and more accessible these days, but maybe you've been a bit wary about buying a home projector. And h ...


Most Commented