macnn

03/26/2008, 12:00pm, EDT

Wednesday, March 26th

Safari 3 license unusually restrictive?

Apple's license for the Safari web browser -- of which v3.1 was recently released -- may be unnecessarily restrictive, an Italian site observes. In spite of the fact that the software is a free download, and ships by default on all Macs, its license currently states that it "allows you to install and use one copy of the Apple Software on a single Apple-labeled computer at a time."

This wording is said to be especially questionable given that Safari is one of few Apple programs available for Windows. There is no mention of PCs or the Microsoft operating system anywhere in Safari's legal documentation, suggesting either that Safari can only be installed on Apple computers, or that PC users are free to copy and share the browser as they wish.


Filed under: Apple, software
Other story tags: Safari, browsers

, , 18comments, del.icio.us, slashdot, digg


18 comments
Reader Reactions (Please use <i></i> for italic text)

subscribe to comments
for this article




Expand All   Global Settings
goof up
0
03/26, 12:15pm, EDT
Apple goofed somewhere on this. The v3.0 license did not limit it to Apple-branded computers.

I wonder whether Apple will be suing all those using Safari on a Dell.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Aug 2001
Status:Offline
perhaps
0
03/26, 12:20pm, EDT
Perhaps there are different licenses with the Windows and Mac versions? (just wondering -- I don't have the Windows Safari)

Perhaps it is a boilerplate agreement that was copy and pasted from a master license they use.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Oct 2001
Status:Offline
retarded story
0
03/26, 12:22pm, EDT
It's free. What do you want for free?
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Jan 2006
Status:Offline
Non-story
0
03/26, 12:45pm, EDT
Does anyone read those those software licenses?

Clearly, if Apple has developed and is allowing downloads and installation on WinBoxes, where's the problem?

Maybe this is a stealth effort to sue everyone who loads he Windows version. What a Microsoftian plan that would be… dumb to the core.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Oct 1999
Status:Offline
boilerplate
0
03/26, 12:55pm, EDT
sounds to me, as suggested above, that someone just copied boilerplate language. Is Apple really going to sue someone or send a cease-and-desist letter if they download Safari and install it on more than one computer? Especially when pretty much everybody updates/downloads Safari through Software Update and hardly anyone (I would imagine) copies the installer from one computer to another?
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Sep 2001
Status:Offline
comments
0
03/26, 1:00pm, EDT
Perhaps there are different licenses with the Windows and Mac versions? (just wondering -- I don't have the Windows Safari)

Nope, I went to the effort of installing 3.1 on my windows box just to check, and it does say it that way. It is also listed that way from the web site. v3.0 didn't read that way, though.

retarded story It's free. What do you want for free?

Um, it's free, but you can't use it legally unless you have an apple branded computer.

BTW, irony would best describe your comment. The site is free, yet your complaining about an article with the argument "but it's free".
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Aug 2001
Status:Offline
so demand a refund
0
03/26, 1:08pm, EDT
for safari. knock yourself out.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Oct 1999
Status:Offline
it just goes to show
0
03/26, 2:02pm, EDT
that even the lawyers don't read software license agreements.

After-purchase agreements/EULA's are totally unenforceable.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Jun 2004
Status:Offline
ah ha!
0
03/26, 2:06pm, EDT
Now Apple is going to sue Window's Safari users to comply with the license agreement--by buying one Apple-branded computer for each copy of Safari they downloaded! Genius.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Aug 2006
Status:Offline
Or...
0
03/26, 2:34pm, EDT
you can just do what I do. Recite "I do not" just before you click the agree button.

It's just as valid as these licenses.

Seriously - who cares what it says, nobody reads it. This case just proves that the people putting it into the software don't even read it.

And despite all the claims of companies to the contrary, software is sold, not licensed. To license it, they would have to have you sign an agreement BEFORE you hand over the money, and they don't do that. It's a sale, you can ignore the "license" unless it gives you MORE rights than you'd have under copyright law and the first sale doctrine (like the GPL does).
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Join Date:Sep 2001
Status:Offline
additional comments:..1..2..Next
Your Comments

In order to post comments: If you are a registered member, please login with your MacNN Forums username and password otherwise please uncheck the checkbox below.


Registered Member?
macnn forums login:

macnn forums password:

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

RSS Feeds

Have the latest content delivered to your desktop via RSS. Use the links below to get access to a specific blog, news, or reviews feed.



  MacNN -all

  MacNN Reviews

  MacNN Podcasts

  iPodNN

  Electronista

  Left Lane News
Turn your laptop into CASH: Sell us your used laptop. Working or not. Get money FAST. Instant online quote. Shipping is FREE.

PowerBookMedic will fix any Powerbook, iBook, iPod: We offer Parts, Hard Drives, Superdrives, Ram Upgrades & Repairs all backed up w/ our 1YR Warranty!

Upload & Share Documents Online.: Sign Up Free and You Could Win $100K.

CHECK OUT THE VIERA FROM PANASONIC: Enter a New Visual Era with Panasonic VIERA HDTVs. An Enhanced Experience.

This Is The #1 Projector For Education And Business: Check Out The Sony VPL-E Series Of Data Projectors. Bright, Stylish, Easy To Use.

AMD for Fair Competition: Better Quality Computers, Lower Prices and More Choice. Learn more.

Buy from The Apple Store, iTunes.com, Amazon.com, TechDepot, OfficeDepot, Computers4Sure, or donate.