Text Size

Adobe clarifies statement on iPhone Flash player

updated 06:30 pm EDT, Wed March 19, 2008

Adobe Flash on iPhone

Despite Adobe's positive-sounding statement yesterday, CEO Shantanu Narayen clarified that he meant Flash on the iPhone would require more than just the iPhone SDK to pull off successfully. Since Flash requires a very close relationship with Safari – something Apple is normally very hesitant to allow – Narayen says it would need to work closely with Apple to develop a satisfactory implementation of Flash for the iPhone, according to CNET.

Apple CEO Steve Jobs has panned both official releases of Flash: Flash Lite for mobile devices and its standard computer equivalent. According to Jobs, Flash Lite is too feature limited, while the standard Flash player is too robust for the multimedia device.

 
Previous Comments

So which is it

03/19, 09:09pm reply

So Jobs doesn't like either version of Flash. So, he is just not going to support it at all. Lovely, Steve, lovely.

lamewing

Forum Regular

Joined: Aug 2004

0

Flash?

03/19, 09:33pm reply

Honestly, what do people want to use Flash for besides looking at videos? I'd rather Adobe stick in a new Flash version the option to embed an alternative H.264 stream which the iPhone can play already.

Anyone thinking that Flash for the iPhone will let you play games is foolish!

dagamer34

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Apr 2007

0

Pandora!

03/19, 11:28pm reply

I want pandora!

lordarka

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Apr 2005

0

flash

03/19, 11:48pm reply

I am not sure what I would do with an iphone or itouch without flash. A few youtube videos and the videos on Apple is about all the video is it's good for. I can wait it out.

pt123

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Sep 2007

0

not just video

03/20, 02:16am reply

Some flavor of Flash could also be useful for the near future of handheld smartphones-- realtime videoconferencing.

Of course we gotta get Steve to swivel that camera around... Apple had that kind of problem with the inverted Apple logo on Powerbooks. It's okay, they fixed it.

Loren

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Mar 2001

-1

Why Flash? Here's why.

03/20, 02:34am reply

True you shouldn't need flash to surf the web but face it you don't have control over web developers. There are sites which are Flash driven. Should they be? Often times no. Should the developer have made a non-flash version? Yes, but it doesn't mean they did. I don't think that not having Flash on a mobile device is alarming except for the fact that Apple touts it as being the "real" web. Well, the real web has Flash so it can't really be the real web. Keep in mind that Flash is sometimes used in more behind the scenes stuff that you may not ever notice visually either. There are multiple file uploaders (not sure if you can even upload on an iPhone anyway - mine is in the mail). Another thing I've seen lately are methods of implementing COMET (reverse AJAX) using Flash to do the talking since it is less prone to memory leaks and crashing your browser. A web developer should plan for graceful degradation but come on this is the real world and I'd be willing to bet that over 90% of sites don't degrade nicely (I'm probably being conservative). Once I get my iPhone, I plan on building up a list of iPhone versions of web sites that I frequent which obviously wouldn't use Flash. The iPhone formatted sites create a much more pleasurable experience, just like my Windows Mobile sites did back when I used WM5. However if the iPhone insists on saying it has the real web then it really should be able support Flash.

JonathanBadeen

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Mar 2008

0

@lamewing

03/20, 02:35am reply

Blame MacNN. Originally Steve said that the flash light is feature-incomplete, and full blown flash is too slow for the iPhone.

Personally I don't want to see ad banners on Mobile Safari, the major bulk of flash data out there, and don't care about lame flash "games". As for video conferencing, if you want the slowest and the least effective implementation of it, yep you would use flash as an environment.

ViktorCode

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Jan 2006

+1

re: pandora!

03/20, 09:28am reply

Yes! Pandora! Not to mention The FuMP! Flash is a useful tool if it's used right and it's stupid that it's not on the iPhone.

devospice

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Aug 2000

0

We want flash

03/20, 11:14am reply

Jobs is sometimes a moron. How long did it take him to see that the iTouch and iPhone could be a great gaming platform to take on Nintendo? Why no SLi for the MacPro? Because Jobs does not do anything with Apple products but sell them. I want to have Flash lite. I might switch it off like I do on my PSP. But I want it. That's all Jobs needs to know. Thanks for my iPhone now bug off and let me put any software I want on MY phone. Remember how long it took him to allow ringtones? Then allow us to make our own ones for free? Not as long as it has taken him to allow an SDK but the point is still valid. Jobs is losing his touch excuse the pun. Android is but a few months away.

henjin

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: May 2007

0

Re: why flash?

03/20, 01:03pm reply

To add to this, customers of mine use a lot of flash files for presentations and lectures.

testudo

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Aug 2001

0

Popular News