Please help us by taking our survey
macnn/electronista

01/23/2008, 10:30am, EST

Wednesday, January 23rd

MacBook Air's Superdrive needs special USB port

The MacBook Air's special processor is not the only example of the ultraportable veering away from Intel's reference designs, Electronista has discovered. People familiar with the internal design of the system have explained that the external Superdrive DVD burner available for the notebook should only be recognized by the Air rather than any computer due to custom requirements from both the subnotebook and its peripheral.

While external optical drives have existed that rely on the USB port alone, the particular power demands of the Apple-made drive should prevent it being used elsewhere; the sole USB port has been boosted past its specifications to supply enough power to use the drive with just the data cable rather than a direct power connection, say contacts.

The computer's port should allow other optical drives; however, the design choice essentially limits the $99 add-on drive to the Air alone. No external AC power connector exists on the external burner to support systems that more closely follow Intel's official power requirements.


Filed under: upgrades/storage, Apple
Other story tags: MacBook Air

, , 43comments, del.icio.us, slashdot, digg, buzz
43 comments
Reader Reactions (Please use <i></i> for italic text)

subscribe to comments
for this article




Expand All   Global Settings
.
0
01/23, 11:03am, EST
Haha, It keeps getting worse with that oversized iPod Companion!
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Jan 2008
User is offline
USB is low power
0
01/23, 11:17am, EST
USB spec max is 2.5 watts for device directly connected and only 2 watts going through a hub whereas Firewire gets up to 45 watts per port 6-pin. So yes USB has always been a very limiting factor for powering devices. I love firewire for self-powered portable HDDs.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Aug 2007
User is offline
Air Motel...
-1
01/23, 11:40am, EST
...once you check-in you can't check-out! A slimey silver trap for McVictims. Advertise your stupidity to the world with a MacBook Air!
Forum Regular
Joined Oct 1999
User is offline
Why no firewire again?
0
01/23, 12:05pm, EST
Seriously now...

Rather than deviating from the USB spec, why couldn't they have found a way to include Firewire? Would the inclusion of Firewire really have added *that* much thickness to the Air?

Sigh..

Maybe v2 will have firewire included?
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Jun 2000
User is offline
What next?
0
01/23, 12:06pm, EST
It's not getting any better for the air - the special drive that you have to buy to use it wont work with anything else, and by implication, no bus-powered USB burners will work with the AIR either (I don't think there are any).

So you're stuck, buy Apple's wonky drive, or go without.
Mac Enthusiast
Joined Jan 2001
User is offline
RTFA
0
01/23, 12:18pm, EST
The special drive is so you can use it with your MBA without external power. So either you buy this drive and get that feature or you buy a third-party drive that has external power. The only thing you can't do is use this drive with another computer. As if you needed to do that.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined May 2004
User is offline
Read it again, Clive
0
01/23, 12:18pm, EST
Other USB devices work with the air, no problem. A little extra juice won't hurt a thing.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Jan 2008
User is offline
not unusual
1
01/23, 12:38pm, EST
Take the Dell Latitude D400 series. The optical drive has a special "Dell Only" usb connector. It can only be used on a Dell system with the correct USB connection.
Mac Elite
Joined Oct 2003
User is offline
Might work in the Cube
0
01/23, 12:41pm, EST
This is exactly the same as the Cube! In fact I wonder if this isn't the perfect companion to the cube as it probably has enough juice on the USB to push the burner (1.1 though).

I still think this is a great computer though despite the whining! I also have a cube that is still working great with 896M of ram and 120G of disk.

Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Feb 2001
User is offline
discotronic is RIGHT!
0
01/23, 1:31pm, EST
discotronic is RIGHT!

The Dell lightweight series (D400, D410 & D420) all use a proprietary cable that provides power & USB. It cannot be used on any other model (except maybe some other Dells). So Apple isnt breaking new ground. So, much ado about nothing!
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Mar 2004
User is offline
additional comments:..1..2..3..4..Next
Your Comments

In order to post comments: If you are a registered member, please login with your MacNN Forums username and password otherwise please uncheck the checkbox below.


Registered Member?
macnn forums login:

macnn forums password:

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

AT&T Cell Phones: Get your next AT&T phone at 1800mobiles.com

PowerBookMedic will fix any Powerbook, iBook, iPod: We offer Parts, Hard Drives, Superdrives, Ram Upgrades & Repairs all backed up w/ our 1YR Warranty!

Buy from The Apple Store, iTunes.com, Amazon.com, TechDepot, OfficeDepot, Computers4Sure, or donate.