toggle

AAPL Stock: 502.21 ( 0 )

Security guru: iPhone malware highly likely

updated 11:20 am EST, Wed November 14, 2007

iPhone malware guaranteed?


A malware attack against iPhone users is almost guaranteed, says Patrik Runald, the security response manager for F-Secure Security Labs. An attack is "80-90 percent likely," he comments, simply by virtue of how easily the iPhone can be hacked. "The 1.1.2 firmware was released last week and was supposed to prevent people from running third-party software," he adds, "but it took only a few hours for the hacking community to break so they could run their third party applications again."

While most hackers have had only positive intentions, such as wanting to install applications or unlock the phone for other carriers, Runald points out that the common technique of "jailbreaking" an iPhone is also what could allow serious damage. "What they're doing is they're breaking out of the iPhone's secure mode, [which] is that you're not allowed to venture outside of the UI." Once this stage is reached, Runald says, "you're out of the shield, you can do anything."

The decision to open up the iPhone to third-party applications in February may have both negative and positive ramifications, Runald observes. Distributing the SDK could in theory make it simpler to develop malware, but at the same time, it could make it possible to install security software, countering the threat. The principal advantage the iPhone will retain is that because it uses a stripped-down version of Mac OS X, there are still fewer avenues of attack than on a desktop system.


by MacNN Staff

TAGS :

 Apple
toggle

Comments

  1. wings_rfs

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Dec 2002

    0

    I smell an idiot

    Right. Just because one is able to "hack" into THEIR OWN iPhone is absolutely no reason to proclaim that someone else can do it remotely. This statement by F-Secure just made me shake my head is disbelief. And these guys are security experts? Or are they trying to sell me something?

  1. njfuzzy

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Apr 2001

    0

    Alas, no...

    I'd like to agree with wings_rfs, but the truth is that the last round of jailbreaking relied on the TIFF overflow vulnerability-- The code was run over the web in a way that any malicious hacker could have exploited as well.

  1. Johnny Niles

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jun 2007

    0

    Um

    That vulnerability was fixed with 1.1.2. So unless you're aware of another vulnerability like that, then wings_rfs is exactly right. Patrik Runald is spreading FUD, because he has no proof that there's a vulnerability on the iPhone (updated to 1.1.2) that would allow malware to run.

    He's speculating, nothing more, and it's not even informed speculation, apparently. If he had even a sliver of proof that such a vulnerability existed on the iPhone (again, updated to 1.1.2), I'm sure he would have shared it with us. Right?

  1. phillymjs

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jun 2000

    0

    fud fud fud fud

    Wake me when this opinion comes from an -independent researcher-, not someone with an agenda or something to sell.

  1. ViktorCode

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2006

    0

    Malware? Where?

    We had iPhone since end of June. Early versions of firmware were plagued with bugs, as we know from many security experts. TIFF bug was known to everyone and hasn't been patched until this week. The question: where's malware on this highly insecure device, mr. Runald? Perhaps mr. Runald knows any secure device that can't be hacked, so he could point Apple where to direct their security efforts? I highly doubt that. Or maybe even better, mr Runald knows a solution for doomed iPhone? Of course! He hints at it: there will be security software that will negate negative SDK impact on security. We are saved!

    I wonder, who will provide us this can't-live-without-it kind of software. Maybe some capable company called F-Secure? After all, they are experts...

  1. ZinkDifferent

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2005

    0

    he has a point...

    yes, 1.1.2 fixed the tiff exploit, which was an incredibly open and exploitable vulnerability - and *could* have been exploited for planting malware.

    It didn't and hopefully most phones upgrade to 1.1.2 -though bear in mind that many, many unlocked phones will continue running 1.1.1, and a great many if those are not fixed with jailbreakme.com - so they remain potentially vulnerable. Also, those improperly jailbroken and with ssh left on could potentially get hacked in over the air/wifi. Newer methods close these openings, but those running earlier hacks could pose (an ever shrinking) target.

    Now, if nothing changed, and Apple would not work towards securing the phone more, he may have more of a point - but I have a feeling that by the time the SDK ships, the iPhone will be a h*** of a lot more secure - I would hope that at one point it would stop operating everything in root mode.

  1. ttrostel

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jul 2007

    0

    Downgrade first

    Please note that in order to jailbreak your iPhone you must DOWNGRADE it to version 1.1.1 which had the TIFF bug.

    Since this individual works for a company that sells anti-virus software, it is possible that his statements are biased. It is 80-90% sure that when third party apps are allowed for the iPhone, F-Secure will want to sell you their software for $$$.

  1. ZinkDifferent

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2005

    0

    not really...

    ttrostel claims: "Please note that in order to jailbreak your iPhone you must DOWNGRADE it to version 1.1.1 which had the TIFF bug. "

    Not really, it is also enough to *NOT UPGRADE* from 1.1.1, seeing as how plenty of phones will remain in the channel that come with 1.1.1 out of the box, and many phones that won't upgrade because they are unlocked one way or another.

    These will remain vulnerable, though obviously their numbers are decreasing as more updates become available.

  1. hswartjes

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Nov 2007

    0

    Scary

    This is scary. I never realized the danger. If I consider the ease with which I can install programs on my Mac, then it is a miracle it still works. Does the same also apply to other devices. My DVD player gets infected with movies almost on a daily basis, and not only DRM movies but sometimes with movies that have no protection at all...

    Seriously, what a piece of nonsense. If Mr. Runald knew how difficult the jailbreaking process on the iPhone really is, I'm sure he would realize that such an "infection" would hardly go unnoticed.

  1. Pennywigeon

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Oct 2007

    0

    OMGWTFBBQ -FUD

    What Patrik Runald was really trying to say.

    " LOK!11!1!!1 LOL WE R HOPNG TAHT W3 CAN R ENOUGH PEOPL3 IN2 THINKNG THEY MAY B AT RISK SO WA CAN ACTUALY HAEV SOME NU WORK OUT TH3RE!!11! OMG WTF WUT I DIDNT EXPLANE SI TEH SITUATION SI SO HIGHLEY UNLIEKLEY TAHT ONLEY A FOL WUD DO TH3M AND NO SACURITY R CAN PROTECT A COMPLATE IDIOT!!11!!1 OMG ALSO FOR THOS3 TAHT UESD HAX 2 UNLOK THEYRE PHONE MAY B VULN3RABLA BUT OF COURSA THEY R VULNERABL3 B/C THAY HAEVNT UPDAETD 2 DA MOST RECENT SACURITY PATCH NOR HAEV TH3Y MAED SUR3 TEH HAK TH3Y UESD DIDNT COMPROMIES DA SECURITY OF DA DEVIEC IN TEH FIRST PLAEC!111!1!!1 WTF BUT I HAEV A QUOTA 2 MET AND INSTEAD OF ACTUALY HAVNG 2 WORK FOR MAH PAYCHEK AND 3ARN IT I WUD RATH3R DRUM UP FUD F3AR AND SE IF TEH DROVES OF MINDLES GULIBL3 IDIOTS WIL COMA 2 M3 FOR TEH SOLUTION!1!!!!111 LOL "

    Ironic that one that works for an "antivirus" company would make an announcement of the likes of this one. Lets see.

    (1) Feed people useless fear. (2) Let the paranoia build. (3) Release a "security software app" in February. (4) Profit.

    F-U-D

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

 
close
Photo
toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

10 Most Read

Recent Reviews

Today Test Monady's's'sdfgdfg'sdffd'dfgd'

Today Test Monady Today Test Monady ...

wwwwwwwww

dfgdfghdfghfghftytryrtytytrytry ...

Flip Ultra HD 2010

Design and the new FlipPort You'd be forgiven for thinking the Ultra HD has gone unchanged on the outside. In many ways, it has; i ...

toggle

Most Commented

10 Most Discussed