toggle

AAPL Stock: 562.29 ( -3.03 )

No service for AT&T-free iPhones?

updated 10:25 am EDT, Tue October 16, 2007

Non-AT&T iPhone service


Apple is refusing to service non-AT&T iPhones even after an owner has legitimately cancelled the contract, an Oregon TV station reports. State resident Jake Durgard explains that after 30 days with his iPhone, he decided that he did not like AT&T's phone service, and had his contract terminated. Not long thereafter, the bottom tray of icons on the Home screen -- including icons for dialing, e-mail and web browsing -- ceased to work, prompting him to bring his iPhone into an Apple Store. Clerks said they would not help without a SIM card however, a requirement Durgard claims is not listed on the iPhone's box or in its warranty.

Pursuing the matter further, Durgard says he called Apple directly, which repeatedly refused to accept the warranty without an active AT&T contract. “Every single time I called, they said they would not service my phone. I told them that I had an AT&T service account, but it’s no longer valid because I had bad service with it and all I want is my phone fixed,” he complains. “They tell me, ‘Sorry, you have to have a two-year active agreement in order to get any hardware replaced or fixed with the phone.’”

Frustration escalated into confrontation when Durgard once again entered an Apple Store, and refused to leave until his iPhone was fixed. Police were called to escort him out, and Durgard now says that he his considering joining a class-action lawsuit to force repairs. The suit has not been identified, although it may be one filed by Paul Holman and Lucy Rivello. Among other accusations, the plaintiffs charge that the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act bars exclusive conditions from warranties, such as attachment to Apple products or AT&T service.


by MacNN Staff

TAGS :

 Apple
toggle

Comments

  1. Terrin

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2006

    0

    Valid complaint

    Well, this guy has a legitimate complaint. He signed up for AT&T and cancelled the service. Now he wants the non-phone features to work. Seems right to me. He didn't hack the phone, and is playing by the terms of the warranty.

  1. elroth

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jul 2006

    0

    maybe not

    What's not clear here is whether he hacked the phone in addition to cancelling his contract. The only info in the story comes from him, which may or may not be the whole story.

    That said, the iPhone should work as an iPod etc. even without a phone contract, but maybe it doesn't...

  1. Constable Odo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2007

    0

    The establishment sucks..

    Down with the overlords. Down with oppression. Let's overthrow the unfair rulers. Down with the pigs. Stick it to the man. Let freedom ring. Yawn.....

    I'd be happy to take his iPhone for one-third it's purchase price. That should make everyone happy.

  1. gskibum3

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Nov 2006

    0

    AT&T?

    I don't need to buy an iPhone to know that AT&T sucks.

    Remember when number portability came to be? AT&T was by far #1 with people jumping ship when their contracts ended!

  1. scruffy

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Oct 2007

    0

    this guy can't read

    the back of the iPhone box sez "Requirements: Minimum new two year wireless service plan with AT&T required to activate all iPhone features, including iPod features." how much clearer could that be?

    what a jamoke. i hope the cops gave him a swift kick in the nuts while they were escorting him out.

  1. sixcolors

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Oct 2001

    0

    f*** apple

    No he is right, Apple has no right to demand a exclusive agreement they be made be followed by a customer. They must warrant a product to be useful for it's intended purpose and it's implied one.

  1. Flying Meat

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2007

    0

    its intended purpose...

    is an AT&T contract enabled phone. It's not implied to be anything else.

  1. drainyoo

    Senior User

    Joined: Feb 2001

    0

    Idiot!

    What is he going to do with his iPhone now that he canceled the service? The iPhone is basically a paper weight without the service. He should have returned the phone when he canceled the contract. Some people are so stupid.

  1. bobolicious

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2002

    0

    As a shareholder...

    ...I want the company to do well financially but also feel Apple may be being too aggressive regarding reasonable use of a product...

    This seems the first reappearance in a while of the classic 'greed & fear' cycle that seemed to plague Apple - too much greed & then remidial heroics when the backlash hit...

    Of course he could sell his iPhone to someone willing to subscribe to AT&T, but not if it is broken due to a reasonably warrantee covered defect...

    This device would seem to be also reasonably useful for wifi, pda, camera & iPod use without cell use, so...

    ...let the backlash begin !

  1. testudo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2001

    0

    Re: guy can't read

    the back of the iPhone box sez "Requirements: Minimum new two year wireless service plan with AT&T required to activate all iPhone features, including iPod features." how much clearer could that be?

    what a jamoke. i hope the cops gave him a swift kick in the nuts while they were escorting him out.


    All it says is that you need a 2 year contract to "ACTIVATE" the iphone. It doesn't say "Warranty service requires 2 year contract". And what it says is true, you can't use the phone without signing up for the plan. But it doesn't say anything that the plan is required to be kept.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

 
close
Photo
toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

MacNN Sponsor

Recent Reviews

iHome iW2 AirPlay speaker

iHome generally isn't known as a luxury brand when it comes to audio, but it is prolific -- the company's docks and speakers are every ...

Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover

One of the iPad's main weaknesses has always been productivity. It's not a question of apps; while it has taken a little time for a na ...

Logitech UE Air Speaker

If maybe a little more slowly than Apple would like, AirPlay is becoming a staple of the wireless speaker market for iOS devices. The ...

toggle

Most Commented