toggle

AAPL Stock: 562.29 ( -3.03 )

PC Mag: New Nano impressive, if imperfect

updated 11:55 am EDT, Fri September 7, 2007

PC Mag 3G Nano review


One of the first official reviews of the third-generation iPod nano has been published by PC Magazine, generally favoring the new player. The only feature absent from the previous Nano, the magazine says, was video, and that has been solved. Owners of the new model have the benefit moreover of a larger, two-inch widescreen, with the best pixel density Apple has yet produced. The magazine also takes a positive view of the accompanying interface, which includes an improved Now Playing screen, and the Cover Flow option from the iPhone.

One of the only complaints is that Cover Flow is "decidedly less sexy" without a touchscreen, instead requiring users to scroll with the clickwheel; it can also bog down, taking time to load album art where iTunes or the iPhone would already be finished.

The remaining two problems are connected to sound output. The stock earbuds are described simply as "crappy," and were ditched in preference of ones from Shure. Similarly, while users can pick EQ presets, there remains no ability to fine-tune settings for better bass or higher mid-tones. This customization is present on other players from the likes of Sony and Samsung. Regardless, the magazine calls the new Nano the "best-designed flash video player on the market in this price range."


by MacNN Staff

(8)

TAGS :

 Apple
toggle

Comments

  1. LemonPepper

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Mar 2006

    0

    Nice headline...

    ...for a product they gave the Editor's Choice and 4.5 out of 5. I think "Near-perfect" is a better choice than "Imperfect", if you actually read the PC mag review.

  1. testudo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2001

    0

    No

    Its not perfect, so it, by default, is imperfect.

  1. bobolicious

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2002

    0

    Custom EQ's for phones...

    ...would bring better audiophile quality to these puppies - generally the biggest difference between higher end headphones is tonality which is easily corrected with either an inline band pass filter or a software loadable custom EQ setting - this may be a fantastic possibility for audio that never existed non-computer devices such as the discman - one might also conceivably correct for various ear canal resonances, with the right software...

  1. nhmlco

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Mar 2007

    0

    Flimsy

    Compared to the 2G nano, this one is... well, flimsy. Definitely less substantial than the 2G, which felt like it was carved out of a solid block of aluminum.

    The "split" navigation scheme, where one side shows the play lists and the other half the album art in a Ken Burns effect feels schizophrenic on such a small screen, neither fish nor fowl. And there seems to be no way to turn it off.

    All in all, if you want a nano for music or workouts I'd get a 2G while supplies last. If you want video, get a touch.

  1. hayesk

    Professional Poster

    Joined: Sep 1999

    0

    EQ settings

    Most people don't need a customizable EQ - it's just for those who like to fiddle. Better earbuds will do far more for sound quality than an equalizer.

    And I agree, Apple's earbuds are crappy - there are much better ones on the market for not much money. Sennheiser MX400s are much better and cost about $30. I like the in-ear models from Shure, etc. but they're cumbersome to use in some situations.

  1. bearcat2000

    Junior Member

    Joined: Aug 2001

    0

    Earbuds

    I understand the included earbuds are not the best, however for most people they do just fine and to suggest that one needs to purchase ones from Shure, which can cost as much or more than the iPod nano itself is purely ridiculous.

  1. LemonPepper

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Mar 2006

    0

    "...by default"?

    Except for your use of "by default", you are correct in a literal sense. I was addressing the implications, and that MacNN's headline downdressed PC Mag's actual review results. I'm sure you understood this from the beginning.

  1. MacnnGregor

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Apr 2004

    0

    Screen

    I was wondering about the new split screen interface. I don't think I would like it as much.

    I wonder also if the smaller scroll wheel makes games too tricky.

    The think many critics are forgetting is that these upgrades include better screens and the doubling of all of the storage at the same price points is incredible!

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

 
close
Photo
toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

MacNN Sponsor

Recent Reviews

iHome iW2 AirPlay speaker

iHome generally isn't known as a luxury brand when it comes to audio, but it is prolific -- the company's docks and speakers are every ...

Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover

One of the iPad's main weaknesses has always been productivity. It's not a question of apps; while it has taken a little time for a na ...

Logitech UE Air Speaker

If maybe a little more slowly than Apple would like, AirPlay is becoming a staple of the wireless speaker market for iOS devices. The ...

toggle

Most Commented