Dvorak voices opinions on Mac experience
updated 11:30 am EDT, Thu July 26, 2007
Dvorak Mac experience
Noted Apple critic John C. Dvorak has written a generally favorable view of recent experiences using an iMac, which he requested for a work project in a Mac-based office. Comparing the system to a PC, he notes that the interface is "slicker," and that he feels less concerned about issues such as viruses and spyware. Mac OS X is also described as seeming "more solid" than Microsoft Windows, which Dvorak attributes to the Mac's Unix substructure.
The primary value of Macs is said to be simplicity: whereas PC users may have to deal with firewalls, anti-virus software and unstable subsystems, a Mac user can often load a program and get his work done without complications.
Dvorak does not universally praise the platform; he argues that in many respects, Macs and PCs run the same programs with equal ability, and a Mac may not always have the best interface. Some examples include the conceit for burning CDs, described as unnecessarily complex, and unspecified general aspects of navigating. He further critcizes "gimmicky" presentation features, such as bouncing icons and animated window minimizing.
He lastly suggests that what may drive people to the Mac is the growing prevalence of online applications, such as Google Docs, reducing the actual demands on a computer. For work-oriented users, Dvorak says, Macs may simply become another smart terminal.












CDs?
07/26, 11:50am reply
Burning CDs on a mac is harder than windows? You put in the CD, it mounts it (and shows it on your desktop), you drag the files to it, and then eject the CD (and click "Burn" ... or simply drag it to the burn icon). So that's as little as two or three clicks (or click-drags).
That's still fewer steps than I have ever managed in Windows, if for no other reason than the various error and "helper" messages that jump in front of me to keep me from doing my intended task. And I have to go into "My Computer" to see if the machine has even mounted it. Just trying on my Work-issued Dell, it looks like I have a minimum of 11 clicks/drags.
Am I missing something?
chaaalie
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Sep 2002
complex CD burning
07/26, 11:52am reply
Yup, I agree...
holding down the control button whiist clicking the mouse button; selecting 'burn' is FAR TOO complex a task for such an amature as Dvorak! (after option-dragging files to the CD desktop icon of course, hey but who dares to follow instructions anymore??)
now consider that the mac os in fact has at least three seperate ways to achive this very same task, errr, like it's soo complex even a old f*** like this dude can't fathom why the programers would need to have so many ways to achieve the same thing...
I recommend retirement for this OUTDATED CHAP, although that will unintentionally WREAK HAVIOC on other golf courses' around the globe...
instead a single blonde college co-ed in a mini skirt would be sooo much more believable, more accurate and hundred times more entertaining...
hokizpokis
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jan 2007
Heh
07/26, 11:58am reply
Dvorak, who has spent decades criticising the Mac, acts as though he hasn't touched one in at least seven years (the OS X era).
What a maroon.
chas_m
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Aug 2001
So....
07/26, 12:03pm reply
All the years of Dvorak's anti-Mac drivel were based on... nothing? This is the first experience he's had with modern Macs?
What a doofus.
Although he did invent the keyboard ;-)
eddd
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Dec 2001
Bouncing icons...
07/26, 12:06pm reply
I wonder why it's "gimmicky" to be able to tell if your application is loading or not, and have the ability to force-quit the application (that you might have launched by mistake) before it fully loads.
I guess if you're used to Windows or Linux which really don't give ANY feedback when an app is loading, other than the hourglass (which indicates all sorts of "you can't use the system now" states).
SubPop
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jan 2006
dvorak useful?
07/26, 12:19pm reply
It should not be forgotten that Dvorak provides an extremely useful sociological role particularly in the context of the evolution of language. Were it not for his presence, the development of new terms through the concatenation of existing phonemes such as "sh*t" and "head" into new and useful constructs would not occur. He therefore makes a valuable contribution to the necessary evolution of language and its obligation to accommodate and express an ever changing society! ;-)
Feathers
Forum Regular
Joined: Oct 1999
Losing Clicks?
07/26, 12:34pm reply
Dvorak must be in need of a few clicks on his blog. He's stated out in the open he criticizes Macs just to drive traffic..
I'm sorry, but man he's a shock jock and that's it.
InfraredAD
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: May 2001
Burnin
07/26, 01:02pm reply
Gotta agree with him on burning.
Our new mac users always have a problem with it
Simple to me but obviously not to others.
Toast solves the problem but is an added expense...
jeph4e
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Dec 2005
Dvorak=Fucktard
07/26, 01:08pm reply
He's still a Windows shill and a general idiot.
Mr. Strat
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jan 2002
Re: burning
07/26, 01:14pm reply
Burning is difficult if you want to do anything other than the most simple task.
Here's one: 1. Burn a file to a CD, take the CD elsewhere, then bring it back. 2. Burn another file to the same CD - how do you do it? It's not easy to figure out unless you already know how.
Apple needs to address issues with Re-writable CDs and Sessions - yes, it can be done with the Disk Utility, but that's not obvious to everyone.
hayesk
Professional Poster
Joined: Sep 1999