U.S. backs Apple's iTunes DRM
updated 01:40 pm EDT, Thu September 14, 2006
U.S. on iTMS restrictions
The U.S. has asked foreign governments to consider the effects of interfering with popular new technologies, pointing to recent scrutiny of Apple's iTunes Music Store as an example of erroneous judgment. The U.S. Justice Department's antitrust chief Thomas Barnett cited recent foreign proposals to impose restrictions on Apple's iTunes service as an example of strict regulation which could discourage innovation and hurt consumers, according to Reuters. A rise in regulatory second-guessing threatens to harm the consumers it claims to help, according to Barnett, who spoke at an antitrust law conference in Washington D.C. in the presence of antitrust officials from Europe as well as Asia. [corrected]
Countries such as Norway and France have issued complaints against Apple's iTunes Music Store in recent months. France recently presented a draft law that Apple called "state-sponsored piracy" which was eventually watered down and finally declared partially unconstitutional after passing the French senate. iTunes' narrow escape in France leads industry watchers to question the possible outcome in other foreign countries such as Norway, which recently met in Iceland to consider whether to file a lawsuit against Apple if the company refuses to lift restrictions that prevent tracks purchased from its own iTunes Music Store from playing on rival music players.
A consumer advocate group initially challenged Apple's iTunes terms of service in early June, winning a preliminary ruling that threatened to force the company to change its iTunes terms of service in Norway. Apple spoke out against the claims in early August, writing a letter to the Norway Consumer Council denying claims of acting illegally by restricting music purchased from its iTunes Music Store to play on its own devices.











spell check please
09/14, 04:14pm reply
Appple?
r00b69
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jan 2006
Since when
09/14, 06:38pm reply
is Scandanavia a country?
e:leaf
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Mar 2006
Umm... no
09/15, 10:09am reply
DRM HURTS consumers, not helps them. It prevents innovation by restricting what the consumers can do with their legally bought music and other content. If the consumers can't do what they want with it, then businesses can't make things that consumers want. Duh.
apple4ever
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jan 2001
Just like a committee
09/15, 10:13am reply
Take a bunch of old people that have no clue about technology or the industry, get them together and let them decide on the laws governing it. They'll get advice from one specific group (completely biased towards one particular local buddy so he can make a bunch of money, part of which pays off several of the influential members of said group).
If they would just ask 10 people who own digital music players, they'd say, "You can download music from the ITM, you can convert it to whatever you want and then play it wherever you want. Opening up the DRM will only allow people to copy music like mad".
Deal
Mac Enthusiast
Joined: Apr 2001