Macs safer than Windows, Internet threats growing

Those had to be some confused Mac users, or they thought that the Trojans were Virii. Is there actual Spyware that exists for the Mac?

"20 percent of Mac owners reported detecting a virus in the past two years"

Is this right? Who did they ask? Even the anti-virus software companies, who have everything to gain from shouting about Mac viruses, have nothing to announce. Or did they mean that 20% of Mac users had detected a _Windows _ virus, sent to them in an email, or by a dodgy web page, etc? If so, that should be mentioned, as it makes the story even clearer.

Look like Consumer Report is making up statistics again.

Man, all you "They're making things up" people should try to understand the comments before you go half-cocked into the "CR is mac-bashing" rants.

What does the statement say? "20 percent of Mac owners reported detecting a virus in the past two years".

OK, did it state that these owners detected Mac viruses? No. Just that they detected a virus. Most AV software for the mac is designed to not only scan for Mac viruses, but also for Windows viruses, so they aren't passed on to other window users later on (esp. in email). So these 20% mac users could easily have detected viruses, its just that most might have been windows viruses.

So, if you're going to rant, please rant on the fact that CR didn't explain this part of the information, as opposed to just saying 20% found a virus.

But don't say they're making things up. They aren't. They just aren't very good at disseminating facts. Big difference.

What does the statement say? "20 percent of Mac owners reported detecting a virus in the past two years".

These could be people running OS9 - that had virii. Believe it or not there are people still using it!

I don't see a big difference between CR "making things up" and CR not being good at "disseminating facts." They have taken it upon themselves to report something, so they should be held responsible for their reporting. This information, or the way it was presented, is irresponsible. It's misleading. And in many ways, it is depicted in a manner that is incorrect.

Someone at CR should have spent more time interpreting their data. Surely someone there is aware that no viruses for the Mac have been detected in the wild? Or someone knows someone who is aware? This is hardly obscure information - it's fairly well publicised. Given this (actual) fact, they should have recognized a problem and investigated.

CR carries an awful lot of credibility, and should be held to a higher standard than the typical tech journalist. Unfortunately, errors along these lines have diminished CR's reputation in my opinion - I rarely take their reports as the highest authority any more.

I don't think OS9 is the answer. It hardly had any viruses either. Nowhere near 20% of any group of Mac users has seen a virus in the last year.

This is definitely a case of poor self-reporting and Mac user ignorance about what a virus is. It's no wonder they don't know what one is, since they have never seen one.

Sure I'd like to think Mac users are all smart, etc., but the facts are that computer users in general are dolts, just like people in general. After all, people think that by collecting coke pull tabs, they can pay for someone's kidney treatments. Dolts I tell you!

I've just read the report and it's vague to the point of being useless. They should have at least pointed out that those 20% viruses don't even affect Macs they were found on - or were they talking about OS9? 20% of Mac users are running OS9?

My guess is this; either 1. the 20% of mac users detecting a virus means when they go onto a windows machine at work or some other computer. 2. the 20% is using Norton or Virex and is detecting windows viruses. 3. the 20% is experiencing kernal panics in older versions of os x, which they may think is a virus, being as it starts scrolling unix code on the screen.

As for the 8% with spyware, they're probably using internet explorer and think that all the popups they ar getting means they have spyware.

Remember, they were reporting on how many people responded to the virus/spyware question, not a technical analysis of their computers at the time of "infection." I get calls all the time from Mac users whose computers have slowed down or done something unexpected. The calls are often "I think I have a virus because I can't print" or similar. Of course a virus is never to blame, and it's usually something simple. But I'll bet most of these respondents really did think they had a virus/spyware even though they were wrong.

CR should have included a sidebar, though, saying how there are no current Mac viruses other than those coming from Microsoft software (Word/Excel/VirtualPC).