Text Size

Report: iPod 'blows away' mobile music challengers

updated 08:20 am EDT, Thu August 11, 2005

iPod not threatened

Global reasearch company Strategy Analytics (SA) concludes that Apple's iPod is not threatened by the current generation of mobile music devices. In the company's latest mobile application benchmark report, "," the firm said its advanced wireless buyer panel benchmark evaluation concluded that first generation mobile music devices "receive a failing grade on both sound quality and feature usability." SA performed head to head benchmarks of the iPod against 4 leading mobile music enabled devices, including the Samsung E720, O2 XM, SEMC V800 and the SPV500. "The 02 XM leads for music feature usability, while the Samsung E720 was rated best overall among a relatively weak set of music phone contenders."

Chris Ambrosio, Vice President of device research, added, "With a 20-plus point performance gap in perceived music quality, handset vendors and operators must do better to realize their visions of mobile music revenues and share support. The next wave of devices from Sony Ericsson (Walkman W600) and Motorola, among others, will have to cross the quality chasm, and provide dedicated music hardware to overcome the weaknesses of these first generation products."

 
Previous Comments

MP3 is poor...

08/11, 09:28am reply

...no matter which way one looks at it - I still can't believe mp3 sells...

Lossless, Ogg, etc is really the only way I would even consider buying online - also the electronics all seem to use a common ground stereo connector (minijack) which creates problems with some 'real' amplifiers... We still have a long way to go...

bobolicious

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Aug 2002

0

optical out on the iPod

08/11, 10:11am reply

Is there a player with optical stereo out? Maybe it's time for Apple to take the lead again.

Paul Huang

Forum Regular

Joined: Sep 1999

0

re: optical

08/11, 10:46am reply

What good would optical be for hearing compressed audio????

ddukes

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Aug 2000

0

Shouldn't this be ...

08/11, 01:19pm reply

... titled, "iPod blows away 1st gen music phones?"

MacnnGregor

Fresh-Faced Recruit

Joined: Apr 2004

0

no one ever said that...

08/11, 01:31pm reply

A 60 GB iPod has to contain compressed audio files.

Paul Huang

Forum Regular

Joined: Sep 1999

0

Popular News